I know how it feels when one person seems only to have bad things to say about your work, so first of all everything I havn't suggested improvements for is great, good job.
For the Reanimator's ring though I'm not sure about the lighting; looks like it could do with another point just above and to the left of the camera. Low intensity, but enough to light up the other side of the skulls and show details without destroying the shadowed look you've gone for.