I hate the idea of an ip wipe, even one that you can choose not to participate in.
My first thought is "Great, a playerbase that's all the same character with different names."
I quit AC to get away from 'the perfect character' syndrome, I don't mind paying the price for my bad decisions, even if that includes rerolling or being 'sub-optimal'. It's easy enough to make a Toon with the same name if you are concerned about losing your identity.
If you implement the ip wipe, can you also please implement life magic, and a nice dungeon where everyone can line up and drain stuff through walls? Or maybe you could put in a rock that soldiers can stand on and shoot Olthoi with no risk so they can powerlevel? Obviously, that would be the perfect game set up for people who are optimal in every way.
Other things you discussed sound like fine ideas to me, I like the overequipping discussion, and other things you talked about just fine.
P.S. I didn't read this whole thread, just chipping in my opinion for Funcom to read. It represents only my reaction to the official statement, nothing more.